王国维“隔与不隔”说与西方直观主义之关系考辩

A Textual Research of the Relationship between the Theory of Wang Guowei’s "The Veiled and the Unveiled" and the Western Intuitionism

作者: 专业:文艺学 导师:凌晨 年度:2018 学位:硕士  院校: 安徽大学

Keywords

Wang Guowei, the veiled, the unveiled, intuitionistic, poetics theory

        百年以来的王国维诗学理论研究历史,给我们呈现了王国维诗学理论的复杂性与其开阔的阐释空间,这种阐释与研究已经进入到更为细致具体的阶段。“隔与不隔”说是近年来王国维诗学理论研究论争的关键之一。本论文试图在跨文化视域下重新审视其“隔与不隔”说的内涵外延,细致考辩“隔与不隔”说同西方直观主义之间的理论关联,尤其注重还原到王国维所处时代的历史文化语境中,探讨王国维对康德、叔本华直观理论的接受问题,并重新考量王国维进行理论创建的初衷与细节。本论文有以下章节:绪论部分开门见山,重点指出本论文的研究目的与意义,全面梳理“隔与不隔”说的研究概况。在跨文化视域下重新审视其“隔与不隔”说的思想内涵,有助于进一步解决悬而未决的理论争锋,考辩“隔与不隔”说同西方直观主义之间的理论关联,有助于把握王国维诗学理论的合理性与完整性。第一章,重回理论文本,细致解读并界定《人间词话》文本“隔”与“不隔”的概念与理论内涵,从“境界说”的理论体系中考量“隔与不隔”的内涵与理论地位。“隔与不隔”是诗词所展现出的自然畅达、直观无碍的审美特征,蕴含着王国维的审美理想,在“境界说”理论体系中具有重要地位。第二章,通过梳理西方直观主义发展脉络,厘清作为王国维思想资源的康德直观理论与叔本华直观理论,进一步考查康德、叔本华直观理论与王国维诗学理论建构之间的交织关系,为细致考辩“隔与不隔”说同西方直观主义之关系奠定理论基础。第三章,通过具体文本来把握王国维诗学理论中“直观”概念的内涵,指出王国维所言的“直观”之对象即“理念”,“直观”的表现方式是“以情观物”和“以物观物”。并从宏观的理论体系、词学批评和创作理念三个角度考察“不隔”与“直观”的内在关联。第四章,指出晚清词坛视域下的王国维“隔与不隔”有着一定的现实针对性。从晚清词坛的历史文化语境中来考量“隔与不隔”说提出的现实意义,并将“隔与不隔”视为一种审美标准,并对“隔与不隔”说做出合适的总结。
    The research history of Wang Guowei’s poetics theory in the past hundred years shows us the complexity of Wang Guowei’s poetics theory and its open interpretation space.This interpretation and research has entered a more detailed and specific stage.The theory of "the veiled and unveiled " is one of the key points in the controversy of Wang Guowei’s poetics theory in recent years.This paper attempts to cross cultural perspective to re-examine "the veiled and unveiled" theory of relationship with Western intuitionism,with particular emphasis on the reduction to Wang Guowei’s historical and cultural context,and to rethink of Wang Guowei’s original intention and detail theory created.This paper has the following chapters:The introduction part straight to the point,and points out the purpose and significance of this paper,a comprehensive combing "the veiled and unveiled"research situation.In the cross cultural perspective to re-examine "the veiled and unveiled "ideological content,help to further solve the theory debate in suspense,debating of "veiled" and "undivided" theory of relationship with Western intuitionism,helps to grasp Wang Guowei’s poetics theory of rationality and integrity.The first chapter,detailed interpretation and definition the text of "Ren Jian Ci Hua",from the "realm" theory system in consideration of "the veiled" and "the unveiled" connotation and theoretical status."the veiled" and "the unveiled" poetry is showing the natural smooth,intuitive affect the aesthetic features,contains Wang Guowei’s aesthetic ideal,has an important position in the "realm" theory.The second chapter,by combing Western intuition development,as Kant’s thought resources to clarify his intuitive theory and Schopenhauer’s theory of intuition,further examines the interwoven relationship between Kant and Schopenhauer theory of intuition and Wang Guowei’s poetics theory construction,detailed study of "the veiled and unveiled " theory relations with the Western intuitionism theoretical basis.The third chapter,through the concrete text to grasp the connotation of Wang Guowei’s poetics theory "intuitive" concept,pointed out that Wang Guowei said"intuition" is the object of "idea","intuitive" style is "object" and "view to to love".The internal relationship between "the unveiled" and "intuition" is examined from three angles of macro theoretical system,lexical criticism and creative ideas.The fourth chapter pointed out that the late Qing Dynasty from the perspective of the theory of "the veiled" and "the unveiled" has a certain practical.From the late Qing Dynasty’s historical and cultural context to consider "the veiled and the unveiled"put forward practical significance,and to make the appropriate summary of "the veiled and the unveiled".
        

王国维“隔与不隔”说与西方直观主义之关系考辩

摘要4-5
Abstract5-6
绪论8-14
    第一节 研究目的与意义8
    第二节 “隔与不隔”说研究概况8-14
第一章 “隔与不隔”说的理论内涵14-19
    第一节 “隔与不隔”说的基本含义14-16
    第二节 “隔与不隔”说与“境界说”之关系16-19
第二章 作为王国维思想资源的西方直观主义思想19-29
    第一节 西方诗学传统中的直观主义19-22
    第二节 王国维与康德的直观理论22-24
    第三节 王国维与叔本华直观理论24-29
第三章 “隔与不隔”说与“直观”之辩29-37
    第一节 王国维诗学理论中“直观”概念的内涵29-31
    第二节 “不隔”与“直观”的内在关联31-37
第四章 晚清词坛视域下的“隔与不隔”37-40
    第一节 “隔与不隔”说的现实针对性37-38
    第二节 “隔与不隔”作为审美标准38-40
结语40-42
参考文献42-46
致谢46-48
攻读硕士学位期间发表的论文48
        下载全文需58


本文地址:

上一篇:蔡居厚诗学批评考论
下一篇:论刘绍棠新时期小说中的地域文化书写

分享到: 分享王国维“隔与不隔”说与西方直观主义之关系考辩到腾讯微博           收藏
评论排行